I haven't used the Tacki Mac Attack Pads. So, I can't comment on them other than to say that if they are as good as their grips (which I now use exclusively) then they are likely worth checking out.
I decided to try BladeTape brand tape replacement on an S15 I hadn't used in a while for ice hockey. I haven't put that stick down since the first time I was on the ice with it. To me, it provides awesome feel. No more "exploding" pucks if you don't cradle or tap it just right when receiving a pass. My shots and sauce also seem better controlled.
I know you asked specifically about roller/inline, but I practice off ice with roller pucks and the BladeTape works just as well with those as ice pucks for me.